Reading Time: 3 minutes

ESWATINI risks undermining investor confidence and disrupting its business environment if it removes foreign traders without first establishing a clear economic empowerment framework.

Southern African Research Foundation for Economic Development (SARFED) Senior Policy advisor Dr George H. Choongwa cautions that enforcing the Citizen Economic Empowerment (CEE) Act No. 18 of 2023 without an accompanying operational policy could expose the economy to unintended consequences.

In SARFED’s latest Economic and Business Commentary, Vol. 10, Issue 19, Choongwa argues that government should exercise caution before taking measures that could affect foreign business operations.

He states: “The Government of Eswatini should avoid operationalization of the Citizen Economic Empowerment Act without having an ideal and functional policy framework in place.”

The CEE Act seeks to expand economic participation among Emaswati, particularly young people and disadvantaged groups, through entrepreneurship, increased citizen ownership, preferential procurement and partnerships between local and foreign businesses. It also provides for the reservation of certain economic activities for citizen-owned enterprises, with the broader objective of promoting employment creation and economic growth.

However, Choongwa argues that while increasing Emaswati’s participation in strategic economic sectors is a legitimate development objective, implementation without clear guidelines could create uncertainty for businesses and investors. He identifies the potential expulsion of foreign businesses as a particular concern, warning that such action could expose the country to negative international perceptions and undermine trade cooperation.

His concerns come amid government’s ongoing enforcement campaign against businesses suspected of violating trading and immigration requirements.

However, Minister of Commerce, Industry and Trade Manqoba Khumalo recently clarified that the inspections were not being conducted under the CEE Act, but under existing legislation, particularly the Trading Licences Order of 1975.

Khumalo said foreign nationals were prohibited from trading on Swazi Nation Land under the existing law, which government was now seeking to enforce more consistently. He also cited cases involving traders without the necessary immigration or business documentation, as well as Emaswati who obtain trading licences and subsequently rent them out to foreign operators.

Minister of Commerce, Industry and Trade Manqoba Khumalo
Minister of Commerce, Industry and Trade Manqoba Khumalo.

The minister said Parliament had resolved that the CEE Act would only become operational once its regulations had completed the parliamentary process.

He also expressed willingness to consider transitional arrangements to avoid inconveniencing communities and businesses that had already committed resources to their operations.

Khumalo has previously maintained that the empowerment legislation is intended to increase local participation without discouraging legitimate foreign investment.

Addressing entrepreneurs at the Manzini Regional Entrepreneur of the Year Awards in July, he said government wanted foreign investors to complement local businesses by bringing in skills and investment in areas where domestic capacity was limited.

“We love foreigners as Emaswati, we love investors, but we want investors that will invest in things where we cannot invest,” he said.

SARFED, however, maintained that government should distinguish between enforcing business compliance and advancing citizen economic empowerment. Although the two objectives complement each other, the organisation argued that compliance measures need to be guided by an appropriate policy framework to ensure consistency and fairness for both local and foreign traders.

The organisation also raised concerns about the financial exposure of foreign businesses, arguing that uncertainty surrounding their continued operations could affect investor confidence and the willingness of traders to maintain working capital in the country.

It said the absence of a dedicated citizen economic empowerment policy was particularly concerning given that government already has the National Policy for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (2024–2029) and the Eswatini Industrial Policy (2023–2033). However, these instruments do not replace a consolidated framework specifically guiding implementation of the CEE legislation.

Choongwa further warned that fragmented implementation could undermine the country’s broader development commitments, including the sustainable development goals and the Eswatini-United Nations Sustainable Development Cooperation Framework 2026–2030.

He therefore recommended that government fast-track a comprehensive policy framework and involve relevant ministries, including finance, commerce, industry and trade, home affairs and foreign affairs, in its implementation.

He also called for industrial gap analysis to establish the reasons behind local business failures before foreign traders are targeted, and stressed that economic empowerment should strengthen domestic participation without compromising Eswatini’s international business relationships.

Investor confidence must be retained

THE country must balance citizen economic empowerment with an investment climate that remains attractive to foreign capital.

SARFED Senior Policy Advisor: Economics Dr George H. Choongwa said strategic partnerships between local and foreign enterprises should form part of the country’s empowerment agenda.

In its latest policy brief, SARFED identifies joint ventures as an important mechanism for transferring business opportunities, skills and economic participation to Emaswati without undermining foreign investment.

Choongwa said government should create conditions that safeguard both local and foreign traders while encouraging effective trade cooperation.

The organisation also highlighted preferential procurement as an opportunity to strengthen local participation in national supply chains.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here