Reading Time: 6 minutes

E2.45 million. That is how much the media in the country has been ordered to pay in defamation damages across just 10 court cases.

I knew media houses were losing defamation cases, but it was only on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, when I joined a panel discussing the Southern Africa Litigation Centre’s (SALC) policy paper, Defamation, SLAPPs and Media Freedom in Eswatini, that I fully appreciated the scale of the problem. Of 14 matters decided between 2014 and 2026, the media lost 11, with damages awards ranging from E60,000 to E550,000.

These are frightening figures for an industry already fighting for survival. Poorly paid journalists work in increasingly inexperienced newsrooms, while ownership interests complicate editorial independence and media houses depend heavily on advertising revenue. The Eswatini Broadcasting and Information Services (EBIS) and Eswatini TV are exceptions, as both receive government subventions. Eswatini Positive News is another fortunate beneficiary, reportedly receiving about E120,000 monthly from public coffers, a claim that warrants scrutiny of its own.

Add a restrictive legal environment, costly litigation and the political sensitivities surrounding investigations into powerful individuals, and the profession finds itself walking a difficult tightrope between financial survival, editorial independence and its responsibility to the public.

The defining characteristic of strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs) is their ulterior purpose of silencing criticism. A lawsuit may appear to be an ordinary attempt to protect someone’s reputation while actually being intended to intimidate critics through expensive legal proceedings. The mere prospect of paying lawyers and spending months defending a claim can be enough to discourage reporting, even before a court determines whether any wrongdoing occurred.

The greater danger lies in what happens afterwards. As legal costs mount and the threat of further litigation hangs over struggling newsrooms, editors become reluctant to approve investigations involving powerful individuals. Journalists learn which stories are best left alone.

Questionable procurement practices may then escape scrutiny, public contracts go unquestioned and money intended for essential services becomes more vulnerable to abuse. Those benefiting from these arrangements have less reason to fear exposure. Over time, withholding information becomes easier, scrutiny is treated as an attack and public officials grow accustomed to disregarding questions about how they spend public funds.

Consider the country in which we practise journalism. More than half the population lives in poverty, while unemployment stands at 33.5% and affects more than half of young people aged 15 to 24.

In Transparency International’s 2025 Corruption Perceptions Index, the kingdom scored just 23 out of 100, ranking 153rd out of 182 countries.

These conditions make it especially important to question how public resources are managed, whose interests government decisions serve and whether institutions entrusted with improving people’s lives are fulfilling their responsibilities. Where livelihoods depend on public services, a failure to investigate misconduct carries consequences far beyond the newsroom.

We cannot afford journalism that trades public interest for gossip and clickbait, bends its reporting to suit political interests or disguises corporate promotion as news. We need journalists capable of investigating public expenditure, scrutinising essential services and establishing facts without fear or favour. That requires more than courage. It demands the discipline to verify allegations, interrogate evidence and afford those implicated a fair opportunity to respond.

One finding in the SALC report was particularly disappointing. Five of the 11 cases lost by the media involved failures to verify information or give those implicated a fair opportunity to respond.

Almost half our defeats arose from lapses in the very editorial standards that should protect us from litigation. It is difficult to make a convincing case for greater legal protection when we sometimes fail to observe the basic principles of responsible journalism.

That contradiction stayed with me after Wednesday’s discussion. For all the legitimate threats we face from restrictive laws and costly lawsuits, how much have we done collectively to address weaknesses within our own newsrooms?

We have struggled to organise ourselves around the principles we expect others to uphold. Poor working conditions have weakened editorial standards, commercial rivalries have frustrated cooperation between newsrooms and years of institutional indecision have left meaningful self-regulation largely unrealised.

Poor editorial practices expose journalists and publishers to legitimate defamation claims, while the lack of collective legal support leaves them vulnerable to lawsuits intended to intimidate them into silence. Both problems discourage the rigorous investigations this country needs. We must challenge threats to press freedom without treating professional accountability as an inconvenience.

Take the juniorisation of newsrooms. Experienced journalists are difficult to retain when salaries are poor and advancement opportunities limited. Editors, themselves inadequately remunerated, must supervise inexperienced reporters while meeting relentless production deadlines.

Verification suffers, mentorship diminishes and mistakes become more likely, exposing struggling newsrooms to costly litigation. Blaming these failures entirely on individual journalists, however, overlooks the conditions in which they work.

Dumisani Moyo’s study of the closure of The Daily News in Zimbabwe offers an important lesson. Although the newspaper faced considerable political hostility, Moyo identified weaknesses in its management and ownership arrangements that also contributed to its difficulties.

His findings raise the uncomfortable possibility that we sometimes attribute too much of our profession’s troubles to external forces while overlooking failures within our own institutions. Restrictive laws and political interference are genuine threats, but they cannot explain away poor editorial oversight, inadequate investment in journalists or ineffective internal accountability.

Herman Wasserman’s research into the relationship between media freedom and commercialism raises an equally difficult question: how freely can journalists investigate wrongdoing when their employers depend on advertising revenue from the very people and institutions they are expected to scrutinise?

Locally, journalists often find themselves investigating businesses and institutions whose advertising helps keep their newsrooms operating.

We cannot therefore, claim to practise journalism without fear or favour while allowing an advertiser’s financial importance or a potential subject’s political connections to influence which investigations receive support.

A journalist need not to be explicitly instructed to abandon a story to understand that pursuing it could jeopardise relationships important to the organisation. Self-censorship then risks being mistaken for sound editorial judgment.

These studies remind us that journalism’s quality cannot be separated from the institutions producing it. Difficult working conditions should never excuse abandoning verification, fairness or accuracy.

We must insist on individual responsibility while demanding that editors and media owners create conditions in which those standards can be upheld. Journalism’s quality depends not only on the stories we publish, but also on the difficult stories we are willing to pursue.

Unfortunately, our response has been undermined by an almost comical rivalry between traditional and online media.

Online media appears delighted whenever newspaper circulation declines, treating established media’s difficulties as proof of superiority. Traditional media retaliate by dismissing online competitors as sensationalists chasing numbers without respecting professional ethics.

Both sides occasionally have legitimate criticisms, but neither gains from celebrating the other’s difficulties. Impressions are not meaningful audience engagement, just as a newspaper’s long history does not automatically guarantee editorial credibility.

Advertisers unfamiliar with digital metrics may be impressed by figures running into millions without asking what those numbers represent.

A post appearing on someone’s screen does not mean they read it, engaged with it or were persuaded by it. Reach, engagement and influence are different things.

Confusing them rewards media houses for attracting attention rather than producing journalism of substance.

This antagonism weakens our capacity to agree on common standards, defend journalists facing intimidation and negotiate collectively for reforms. It also leaves individual reporters bearing risks that should concern the profession as a whole.

When one newsroom faces an attempt to silence legitimate reporting, competitors should recognise that the precedent could eventually threaten them too. Which brings me to the National Association of Journalists and the Editors Forum.

Their awards, stakeholder engagements and industry events deserve recognition, but organisations must ultimately be judged by the institutional problems they help resolve. We need more than occasional statements of concern. Journalists facing expensive claims need practical legal support, while newsrooms need credible systems for correcting errors and enforcing standards.

Consider the legislative environment in which we operate. More than six decades after independence, the Books and Newspapers Act of 1963 still imposes registration requirements on newspapers, while the Proscribed Publications Act of 1968 gives authorities powers to prohibit publications.

The Computer Crime and Cybercrime Act of 2022 has raised concerns about provisions exposing people to prosecution over online publications. Criminal defamation allows journalists to face prosecution for allegedly damaging reputations, while contempt of court laws can restrict reporting on judicial proceedings.

The Official Secrets Act of 1968 further discourages disclosure of government information through criminal penalties, complicating investigations into matters of public interest.

These laws continue to constrain journalism, while civil defamation claims expose journalists and media houses to potentially crippling damages. Reform requires sustained engagement with Parliament and civil society, but such advocacy is difficult without a coherent professional agenda and demonstrable commitment to accountability.

We cannot credibly demand that powerful institutions answer difficult questions while resisting scrutiny of our decisions.

The question is not whether journalists should be protected from intimidation or held accountable for mistakes. Both are necessary.

How embarrassingly ironic then that a profession which makes a living demanding accountability from everyone else has struggled so spectacularly to hold itself to the same standard.

We cannot expect the public, or those in power, to take our profession seriously when we fail to demonstrate that we take our own standards, institutions and responsibilities seriously enough.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here